The Best Wedding Gifts Are the Ones with Heart

There’s something incredibly special about choosing a personalized wedding gift—especially for someone you’ve watched grow up.

This summer, Jeff and I are headed to Nashville for our first-ever visit… to attend the wedding of the little girl who once lived next door. The one who played in our yard and grew up right before our eyes. Now she’s getting married—and we’ve been thoughtfully planning out every detail of her gifts.

For her bridal shower, I’m bundling together a few of my favorites:

• My Happily Ever After kitchen towel — sweet and timeless

• The “I have found the one whom my soul loves” towel — taken from Song of Solomon 3:4

• A set of wine glasses from her registry

• And a handcrafted wood cutting board that Jeff is making just for her (not for sale, but made with love)

Then for the wedding gift, I’m creating one of our Personalized Mr. & Mrs. Lighted Ornaments. I’ll wrap it up with a meaningful card and a bit of cash they can use for their honeymoon or new home. It’s the kind of keepsake they’ll hang on their first Christmas tree—and hopefully every one after.

It got me thinking: some of the most cherished gifts don’t come from the registry. They come from the heart—made or chosen with intention, prayer, and love. If you’re heading to a wedding this summer, here are a few Catholic wedding gift ideas that are always well received:

Thoughtful Gift Ideas for the Bride and Groom

1. Personalized Marriage Wood Cross
A beautiful, faith-filled gift for the couple’s new home. Engraved with their names and wedding date, it’s one of my favorite Catholic keepsakes for newlyweds.

2. Mr. & Mrs. Lighted Personalized Ornament
Elegant and personalized, this lighted ornament adds a soft glow to their first Christmas together. A meaningful touch to celebrate their new life as husband and wife.

3. Our First Christmas Personalized Ornament
Another lovely option, especially for couples who love traditional keepsakes. Add their names and wedding year for a gift they’ll treasure every December.

4. Happily Ever After Kitchen Towel
A sweet sentiment that makes a perfect bridal shower gift—simple, beautiful, and practical.

5. “I have found the one whom my soul loves” Kitchen Towel
Inspired by Scripture, this towel is ideal for Christian couples or anyone who values faith in their home.

6. Any of our faith-inspired towels
You can mix and match them to create your own bridal shower gift set—tie with ribbon, add a wooden spoon or cookbook, and you’re good to go.

Custom Gifts for Newlyweds That Tell a Story

A meaningful gift doesn’t have to be expensive. Whether it’s a handmade towel, a lighted ornament, or a personalized wall cross, what matters most is the love behind it. These are the gifts that last—the ones that become part of a couple’s everyday life or cherished holiday traditions.

Shop the Wedding Collection